How to Exclude Specific Products & Collections from Shopify Discounts

Last Black Friday, a fashion retailer ran "20% off everything" and accidentally discounted their just-launched winter collection. Those products had 35% margins. After the discount, they made almost nothing on those sales. Sound familiar?

Discounts drive sales. But uncontrolled discounts destroy margins. The real skill is knowing what NOT to discount. If you want to exclude products from discounts Shopify offers, you need the right strategy and tools.

Here is the good news. Shopify offers some built-in exclusion tools. And for advanced control, apps like Growth Suite fill the gaps. This guide covers BOTH approaches so you can protect your profits while still running great promotions.

What Does "Excluding Products from Discounts" Actually Mean?

When you exclude products from discounts Shopify stores use, you prevent specific items from receiving discount codes or automatic discounts. It is about protecting certain products while letting others participate in your promotions.

There are two main approaches. You can use native Shopify exclusions (free, built into your store). Or you can use app-based advanced exclusions for more control. Both have their place depending on your needs.

Why does this matter? Three big reasons:

• Margin protection: Keep your profits on thin-margin products
• Brand agreements: Comply with vendor MAP pricing requirements
• Strategic pricing: Protect new arrivals and premium items

Let's start with what Shopify offers out of the box. For many merchants, these native tools are enough. For those who need more, we will cover advanced solutions in Part 2.

Shopify's Built-In Exclusion Methods (Overview)

Here is something important to understand. Shopify does not have an "Exclude" button. Instead, it works by inclusion. You specify which products or collections GET the discount. Everything else is excluded by default.

This applies to both Discount Codes and Automatic Discounts. The shopify discount exclusions approach is simple but requires updating your discount every time you add new products that should be eligible.

There are two native methods:

1. Product-based selection: Choose specific products manually
2. Collection-based selection: Choose specific collections

Method 1: Excluding Products from Discount Codes (Shopify Native)

This is the most common way to exclude products from discounts Shopify merchants use. Let's walk through exactly how to set it up.

Creating a Discount Code with Product Exclusions

Follow these steps to create product exclusion rules in Shopify:

1. Step 1: Go to Discounts in your Shopify Admin
2. Step 2: Click Create Discount and select Discount Code
3. Step 3: Choose your discount type (Percentage, Fixed Amount, etc.)
4. Step 4: Under "Applies to", select either Specific collections or Specific products
5. Step 5: Leave out any products or collections you want to exclude
6. Step 6: Set other parameters (minimum requirements, usage limits, dates)
7. Step 7: Save your discount

The Pros and Cons of This Method

Real-World Example

The Hidden UX Problem: Customer Discovers Exclusion at Checkout

Here is the big problem with native shopify discount exclusions. Customers do not know a product is excluded until they reach checkout.

Think about the customer journey:

• They browse your store and see your "20% OFF" banner
• They assume it applies to everything
• They add an excluded product to their cart
• They go to checkout and enter the code
• The discount either does not apply or only partially applies
• They feel deceived. They abandon the cart or leave a negative review

Method 2: Excluding Products from Automatic Discounts (Shopify Native)

How Automatic Discounts Work Differently

Automatic discounts apply at checkout without a code. The customer does not need to enter anything. The discount just appears. But the same inclusion logic applies. You specify what gets the discount, and everything else is excluded.

Step-by-Step Setup

1. Step 1: Go to Discounts and click Create Discount
2. Step 2: Select Automatic Discount
3. Step 3: Set discount type and value
4. Step 4: Under "Applies to", choose Specific collections or Specific products
5. Step 5: Select only the products or collections that SHOULD receive the discount
6. Step 6: Everything else is automatically excluded
7. Step 7: Save and activate

When to Use Automatic Discounts vs. Codes

Method 3: Using Collections to Manage Exclusions (Shopify Native)

This is the most scalable native approach for collection discount controls. Instead of selecting products for each discount, you create a dedicated collection for discount-eligible products.

Creating a "Discount Eligible" Collection

Here is how to set up collection discount controls the right way:

1. Step 1: Go to Products then Collections then Create Collection
2. Step 2: Name it "Sale Eligible" or "Discount OK"
3. Step 3: Choose collection type: Manual or Automated
4. Step 4: For automated, set conditions like:
   • Product tag is equal to "sale-ok"
   • Product type is not equal to "New Arrival"
5. Step 5: Save collection
6. Step 6: Use this collection in all your discounts

Automated Collection Conditions for Exclusions

Important note: Shopify's automated collection conditions CAN filter by vendor and compare-at price. This is useful for building collections. But it does NOT apply to discounts directly. The discount still goes to the whole collection.

The Limitation: Team Discipline Required

This method only works if your team follows the system. Every new product needs proper tags. Forgotten tags mean products get incorrectly included or excluded. There is no automated validation. It relies on human consistency.

Limitations of Shopify's Native Exclusion Methods

Native methods work well for simple setups. But they have real limitations that hurt growing stores. Let me show you what you cannot do with native Shopify and why it matters.

Math Example: The Double Discount Problem

This is why you need to prevent double discounting. Look at these numbers:

If your store is small and simple, Shopify's native tools may be enough. But if you are managing multiple vendors, running frequent promotions, or need protection against double-discounting, you need more control. That is where Growth Suite comes in.

When Native Shopify Is Not Enough

Native Shopify is great for basics. But as your store grows, you need more sophisticated product exclusion rules. Here are the signs you have outgrown native exclusions:

• Multiple vendors with different margin profiles
• Products frequently marked down (compare-at prices)
• Large orders eating into your discount budget
• Team struggling to keep up with tagging
• New products accidentally getting discounted

What Growth Suite adds to your shopify discount exclusions:

• Rule-based exclusions that apply automatically
• No tagging required because it uses existing product data
• Protection for new products without manual updates
• Controls Shopify does not offer (vendor, compare-at, max discount)
• Transparent UX where customers see exclusion status on product page, not at checkout

The Game-Changer: Exclusions Visible on Product Page

This is the most important difference between native Shopify and Growth Suite. Remember the "Checkout Surprise" problem? Growth Suite solves it completely.

Why This Matters More Than You Think

With Shopify native: Customer discovers exclusion at checkout. They feel frustrated. They abandon their cart.

With Growth Suite: Customer sees it immediately on the product page. They have clear expectations from the start.

This is not just better UX. It is better for your conversion rate and brand trust.

How Growth Suite Handles Excluded Products

The transparent approach works like this:

• Growth Suite displays a campaign box on eligible product pages (countdown timer, discount offer, etc.)
• When a product is EXCLUDED, the campaign box simply does not appear
• Customer browsing an excluded product sees NO discount offer
• Customer browsing an eligible product sees the full campaign experience

The Business Impact

• No "bait and switch" feeling because customers know before adding to cart
• Fewer abandoned carts from checkout surprises
• No angry customer service tickets about "broken" discount codes
• Brand maintains trust and transparency

Real-World Scenario Comparison

Growth Suite Exclusion Method 1: Exclude by Vendor

This solves the multi-brand store problem. If you want to exclude vendors from discounts, Growth Suite makes it easy.

Why Vendor-Based Exclusions Matter

Multi-brand retailers carry products from many suppliers. Each vendor may have different:

• Margin profiles: Some vendors give 60% margin, others only 25%
• MAP agreements: Minimum Advertised Price requirements
• Brand protection: Requirements to maintain brand value

Discounting all vendors equally does not make sense. You need to exclude vendors from discounts based on your agreements and margin profiles.

How to Set Up Vendor Exclusions

Growth Suite Exclusion Method 2: Exclude by Title Keywords

This method lets you protect products by their naming convention. No tagging required because it uses your existing product titles.

How Keyword Exclusions Work

Growth Suite scans product titles for specific text strings. Any product containing that text gets excluded from discounts. It works with partial matches. For example, "Limited" catches "Limited Edition" products.

Common Keywords to Exclude

Growth Suite Exclusion Method 3: Compare-At Price Protection

This solves the double-discounting problem. It is essential for margin protection discounts.

The Double Discounting Problem Explained

"Compare-at price" in Shopify means a product is already on sale. It shows as strikethrough pricing like $80 $100. The problem? Discount codes can STILL apply on top. Customers get discount-on-discount. Your margins disappear.

Why This Happens More Than You Think

• Seasonal sales overlap with ongoing promotions
• Team members do not check which products are already marked down
• Customers actively look for stackable discounts
• Shopify has NO native protection against this

This is why prevent double discounting should be a priority for every store running multiple promotions.

Growth Suite Exclusion Method 4: Maximum Discount Limits

This protects you against large order discount abuse. It is a critical part of margin protection discounts for high-AOV stores.

The Big Order Problem

Percentage discounts scale with order size. Look at what happens:

• 25% off a $100 order = $25 discount (fine)
• 25% off a $2,000 order = $500 discount (problem)
• 25% off a $10,000 order = $2,500 discount (emergency)

High-AOV stores and B2B merchants are especially vulnerable to this.

How Maximum Discount Limits Work

Growth Suite Bonus: Behavioral Targeting (The Ultimate Exclusion)

Beyond product exclusions, consider VISITOR exclusions. This is an advanced way to exclude products from discounts Shopify stores can use. Or more precisely, exclude certain visitors from seeing discounts at all.

Here is the concept: Not everyone needs a discount to buy. "Dedicated buyers" will purchase at full price. Showing them a discount just gives away margin unnecessarily.

The Dedicated Buyer Concept

Some visitors come to your store ready to buy. They have done their research. They know what they want. They are going to purchase. Giving these visitors a discount does not increase conversion. It just reduces your revenue.

How Growth Suite Handles This

• Tracks visitor behavior in real-time
• Identifies purchase intent signals
• Only shows discount offers to visitors who appear hesitant
• "Dedicated buyers" never see the offer because they pay full price

Comparison: Native Shopify vs. Growth Suite Exclusions

Here is the complete comparison to help you decide which approach fits your needs for shopify discount exclusions.

Decision Guide

FAQ: Product and Collection Exclusion Questions

Conclusion: Building Your Exclusion Strategy

Exclusions are profit protection tools, not limitations. When you exclude products from discounts Shopify gives you some basic tools. But for real control, you need a systematic approach.

Your Action Steps

1. Audit your catalog: Identify products that should never be discounted
2. Start with native Shopify: Use collections to organize discount eligibility
3. Monitor for problems: Watch for double-discounting, large order abuse, vendor issues
4. Add Growth Suite when needed: If manual management becomes a burden or margins suffer