Growth Suite
Solutions Pricing Growth Masters Partner Program
Try For Free
Tool

BOGO Margin Calculator: Is Your Promotion Profitable?

Calculate your actual BOGO profit before you launch. Enter your product price and cost, see exactly what happens to your margins—and get warned if you're about to lose money.

Muhammed Tüfekyapan By Muhammed Tüfekyapan
6 min read
BOGO Margin Calculator: Is Your Promotion Profitable? - Growth Suite

Key Takeaways

  • Buy 1 Get 1 Free = 50% off per unit—the 'free' product costs you, not the customer
  • Below 50% margin, B1G1 loses money on every sale. Below 33% margin, B2G1 loses money
  • Use this BOGO profit calculator BEFORE launching—not after you've already lost margin
  • BOGO moves more units but at lower profit per unit. Know your goal: volume or profit?
  • Dedicated buyers using BOGO would have paid full price. That's hidden margin loss
  • Consider alternatives: tiered discounts and intent-based offers protect margins better

Buy One Get One Free. Sounds great to customers. But what does it actually do to your profit?

Here's what most merchants don't realize: that "free" item isn't free to you. You still pay for it. And if your margins aren't healthy enough, BOGO promotions can actually lose you money on every single sale.

This BOGO margin calculator shows you exactly what happens when you run a Buy X Get Y promotion. Enter your numbers. See the truth. Then decide if it's worth it.

What This Calculator Shows You:

  • Your actual profit per BOGO transaction
  • How BOGO compares to full price and percentage discounts
  • Warning if you're about to lose money
  • Break-even analysis: how many BOGO sales to match one full-price sale

BOGO Margin Calculator

Find out if your buy one get one free promotion is actually profitable

$

Your regular selling price

$

Your cost per unit (COGS)

Common BOGO structures

Your BOGO Profit Per Transaction

$12.00

Profitable, but significantly less than full price

Customer Gets

2 units

Customer Pays

$60.00

Your Total Cost

$48.00

Your Profit

$12.00

Profit Per Unit

$6.00

Scenario Revenue Your Cost Profit Units
Full Price (1 unit) $60.00 $24.00 $36.00 1
BOGO (2 units) $60.00 $48.00 $12.00 2
50% Off (1 unit) $30.00 $24.00 $6.00 1

To match the profit of one full-price sale, you need:

3 BOGO transactions

How BOGO Profit Math Works

The BOGO profit calculator uses a simple formula. But the results often surprise merchants.

BOGO Profit Formula:

Profit = (Price × Units Paid) − (Cost × Total Units)

Where:

  • • Units Paid = items customer pays for
  • • Total Units = items customer receives (paid + free)

Let's walk through an example:

Product: $60 selling price, $24 cost (60% margin)

Buy 1 Get 1 Free:

  • Customer pays: $60 (for 1 item)
  • Customer gets: 2 items
  • Your cost: $24 × 2 = $48
  • Your profit: $60 − $48 = $12

Buy 2 Get 1 Free:

  • Customer pays: $120 (for 2 items)
  • Customer gets: 3 items
  • Your cost: $24 × 3 = $72
  • Your profit: $120 − $72 = $48

Key Insight:

Buy 1 Get 1 Free is effectively a 50% discount per unit. But you're moving 2 units instead of 1. Whether that's good depends on your goals AND your margin.

BOGO Types Comparison

Different BOGO structures have different impacts on your margins. Here's how they compare:

BOGO Type Customer Pays Customer Gets Effective Discount Min. Margin Needed
Buy 1 Get 1 Free 1× Price 2 units 50% per unit 50%+
Buy 2 Get 1 Free 2× Price 3 units 33% per unit 33%+
Buy 3 Get 1 Free 3× Price 4 units 25% per unit 25%+
Buy 4 Get 1 Free 4× Price 5 units 20% per unit 20%+

The more items required to buy, the less you're giving away. Buy 2 Get 1 Free is safer than Buy 1 Get 1 Free. But it also requires customers to commit to buying more upfront.

When BOGO Math Makes Sense

BOGO Works When:

  • Your margin is healthy (60%+) — At 60% margin, B1G1 still profits. At 40% margin, B1G1 loses money on every sale.
  • You need to move inventory fast — Seasonal items, expiring products, or when storage costs exceed holding value.
  • Customers naturally buy multiples — Consumables (skincare, supplements), basics (socks, t-shirts), gift-worthy items.

BOGO Doesn't Work When:

  • Your margin is under 50% — B1G1 at 40% margin = guaranteed loss. Even B2G1 at low margins is risky.
  • Customers only want one — Furniture, electronics, statement pieces. Forcing BOGO feels unnatural.
  • You're training discount dependency — Frequent BOGO = customers wait for it. You become a "sale brand."
Critical Guide

Buy X Get Y (BOGO): Before You Run This Campaign

BOGO excites customers—but often destroys margins. Learn when it makes sense, when it doesn't, and what alternatives might solve your problem better.

Read the Full Guide

The Dedicated Buyer Problem

The BOGO profit calculator shows your profit per transaction. But it doesn't show how many of those buyers would have paid full price.

The hidden cost:

  • Some customers were ready to buy at full price
  • You showed them BOGO, they took it
  • You gave away a free product to someone who didn't need convincing

Example: If 30% of your BOGO buyers would have bought at full price anyway, you're not just making $12 per transaction instead of $36. You're losing $24 × 30% = $7.20 per transaction to dedicated buyers who didn't need the incentive.

The Real Question:

Can you target BOGO only to hesitant visitors? Or are you broadcasting it to everyone?

A Smarter Alternative: Intent-Based Offers

What if instead of BOGO for everyone, you showed targeted offers only to visitors who need a nudge?

Growth Suite's approach:

  • Tracks visitor behavior in real-time
  • Identifies hesitant vs. dedicated buyers
  • Shows personalized offers only to those who need them
  • Dedicated buyers pay full price (margin protected)

Why this matters for BOGO: BOGO is a blunt instrument—everyone sees it. Intent-based offers are surgical. You convert hesitant visitors without giving away margin to everyone else.

Key Takeaways

Summary: BOGO Profitability

  1. Calculate before you launch — Use this BOGO margin calculator every time you consider a BOGO promotion.
  2. B1G1 = 50% off per unit — The "free" item costs you. Make sure your margins can handle it.
  3. Margin threshold matters — Below 50% margin, B1G1 loses money. Below 33%, B2G1 loses money.
  4. Units moved ≠ profit made — Moving 2 units at $12 profit isn't better than 1 unit at $36 unless you have inventory or volume goals.
  5. Dedicated buyers cost you extra — Some BOGO takers would have paid full price. That's hidden margin loss.
  6. Consider alternatives — Free Gift thresholds, tiered discounts, or intent-based offers might achieve your goal with less margin damage.
14-Day Free Trial

Increase profits, not just sales.

Growth Suite detects hesitant visitors and delivers unique, smart discounts only when needed. Stop giving money away to everyone.

Try Growth Suite Free

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I calculate BOGO profit margin?
Use the BOGO profit formula: Profit = (Price × Units Paid) − (Cost × Total Units). For Buy 1 Get 1 Free: customer pays for 1 unit but receives 2, so your cost doubles while revenue stays the same. Example: $60 price, $24 cost. Customer pays $60, gets 2 units. Your cost = $48 (2 × $24). Profit = $60 − $48 = $12.
Is my BOGO promotion profitable?
It depends on your margin. For Buy 1 Get 1 Free, you need at least 50% gross margin to break even. For Buy 2 Get 1 Free, you need at least 33% margin. Use a BOGO margin calculator to check: if your cost × total units given exceeds what the customer pays, you're losing money on every sale.
What margin do I need for Buy 1 Get 1 Free?
You need at least 50% gross margin for B1G1 to be profitable. At exactly 50% margin, you break even (zero profit). Above 50%, you make profit but less than full price. Below 50%, you lose money on every BOGO sale. Example: At 40% margin ($60 price, $36 cost), B1G1 loses $12 per transaction.
Is Buy One Get One really 50% off?
Yes, effectively. With B1G1, the customer pays full price for 1 item but receives 2. The effective discount is 50% per unit. However, unlike a straight 50% off, BOGO forces the customer to take 2 units—which means you're giving away more total inventory than a percentage discount on a single item.
What is a BOGO break even calculator?
A BOGO break even calculator shows how many BOGO transactions you need to match the profit of one full-price sale. Formula: Full Price Profit ÷ BOGO Profit = transactions needed. Example: If full price profit is $36 and BOGO profit is $12, you need 3 BOGO transactions to match 1 full-price sale.
How do I calculate Buy 2 Get 1 Free profit?
For B2G1: Customer pays 2× Price, receives 3 units. Profit = (Price × 2) − (Cost × 3). Example: $60 price, $24 cost. Customer pays $120, gets 3 units. Your cost = $72 (3 × $24). Profit = $120 − $72 = $48. This is better than B1G1's $12 profit because you're giving away less percentage-wise.
Which BOGO type is most profitable?
Buy 3 Get 1 Free or Buy 4 Get 1 Free are more profitable than Buy 1 Get 1 Free. The more items required to buy, the lower your effective discount. B1G1 = 50% off per unit, B2G1 = 33% off, B3G1 = 25% off, B4G1 = 20% off. Choose based on how many items customers naturally want.
Is BOGO better than percentage discount?
Not necessarily. B1G1 equals 50% off per unit but moves 2 units. 50% off moves 1 unit with less total product cost. BOGO is better for clearing inventory or consumables. Percentage is better for targeted offers and margin protection. Use a calculator to compare actual profit scenarios for your products.
Why am I losing money on BOGO?
You're likely losing money because your margin is too low. B1G1 requires 50%+ margin to be profitable. If your product cost is more than half the selling price, you'll lose money on every B1G1 sale. Also check: are you giving BOGO to customers who would have paid full price? That's hidden loss.
How do I make BOGO profitable?
Three ways: (1) Use B2G1 or B3G1 instead of B1G1—they give away less percentage-wise. (2) Only run BOGO on high-margin products (60%+). (3) Target BOGO to hesitant visitors only, not loyal customers who would pay full price. Always calculate profit before launching.
What's the BOGO profit formula?
BOGO Profit = (Price × Units Paid) − (Cost × Total Units). Units Paid = items customer pays for. Total Units = items customer receives (paid + free). For Buy X Get Y Free: Units Paid = X, Total Units = X + Y. Example B2G1: Profit = (Price × 2) − (Cost × 3).
Should I run BOGO or give a free gift?
Free gift with purchase threshold is often better than BOGO. It encourages higher cart value (Spend $100, get free gift) rather than just doubling units of one product. Free gift also feels more premium and doesn't train discount dependency. Consider your goal: moving specific inventory (BOGO) vs. increasing AOV (free gift threshold).

References & Sources

  • [1] Creating Buy X Get Y discounts in Shopify - Shopify Help Center (2024) View Source →
  • [2] BOGO vs Percentage Off: Which is Better? - SmartSMS Solutions (2024) View Source →
  • [3] The Psychology of BOGO Promotions - Journal of Business Research (2019) View Source →
  • [4] E-commerce Promotional Strategies and Margin Impact - Harvard Business Review (2024) View Source →
  • [5] Retail Promotion Profitability Analysis - MIT Sloan Management Review (2024) View Source →

Ready to Implement These Strategies?

Put this knowledge into action with Growth Suite. Start converting more visitors into customers with smart, AI-powered campaigns.

Start Free Trial Book a Demo
Muhammed Tüfekyapan

Muhammed Tüfekyapan

Founder of Growth Suite

Muhammed Tüfekyapan is a growth marketing expert and the founder of Growth Suite, an AI-powered Shopify app trusted by over 300 stores across 40+ countries. With a career in data-driven e-commerce optimization that began in 2012, he has established himself as a leading authority in the field.

In 2015, Muhammed authored the influential book, "Introduction to Growth Hacking," distilling his early insights into actionable strategies for business growth. His hands-on experience includes consulting for over 100 companies across more than 10 sectors, where he consistently helped brands achieve significant improvements in conversion rates and revenue. This deep understanding of the challenges facing Shopify merchants inspired him to found Growth Suite, a solution dedicated to converting hesitant browsers into buyers through personalized, smart offers.

Previous

BOGO vs Percentage Discount: Which Is Better for Your Store?
Next

7 BOGO Mistakes That Kill Your Profit Margins (And How to Fix Them)

In This Article