Should I use different recovery strategies for different cart values?

As a Shopify store owner in the fashion accessories space, I've been wrestling with cart abandonment for months. My average order value ranges from $50 to $300, and I've noticed something interesting: the way a customer with a $60 cart behaves is completely different from someone about to complete a $250 purchase. Initially, I was using a one-size-fits-all approach to cart recovery—the same discount, the same messaging, the same timing. But my conversion rates told a different story. Lower-value carts seemed to need a quick, immediate nudge, while higher-value carts required more nuanced, trust-building communication. I started wondering: should I really be treating a $50 cart abandonment the same way I'd approach a $250 cart? The stakes, the customer psychology, and the potential revenue impact are fundamentally different. I need a strategy that understands these nuances—something that can dynamically adjust recovery tactics based on cart value, without feeling generic or desperate.